Today, the Victorian Auditor-General's Office (VAGO) has released its long-awaited report into Victoria's Firefighting Fleet.
VFBV welcomes the Auditor General's findings and recommendations. The report highlights decades of underinvestment in CFA's firefighting fleet and demonstrates that even following recent government announcements, there remains a significant shortfall in funding that is preventing CFA to provide fit-for-purpose fire trucks that are safe, reliable and up to the job required.
The report confirms VFBV's detailed analysis about the inadequacy of current CFA budgets and validates the detailed concerns raised by VFBV on behalf of all CFA volunteers about the impact these funding gaps are having on CFA's ability to protect Victorian's.
We have described current arrangements as setting CFA volunteers up to fail. While CFA volunteers are attending more and more incidents, funding is falling woefully short of what is required. With increasingly fire risk from busier than usual fire seasons and the impacts of climate change, CFA is only receiving a fraction of what it needs to keep Victorian's safe. These issues were comprehensively covered in VFBV’s submissions found at the bottom of this page: Parliamentary Inquiry into 2026 Fires
The report has drawn on VFBV analysis submitted to this year's Parliamentary Inquiry, as well as detailed analysis conducted well prior which was critical in firming up the need for an independent audit by an oversight body. This work was flagged in VAGO's three-year workplan.
The report highlights the critical role oversight bodies such as VAGO, the Victorian Ombudsman and IBAC play in cutting through political spin and commentary.
While VFBV comment and analysis are critically important to highlight the unique perspectives of volunteers, the report demonstrates the value of VFBV's professional and strategic advocacy that engages with decision makers across Government, fire agencies and the broader emergency management sector including oversight bodies. The report places the evidence in public domain by an independent, trusted and credible body, and places beyond doubt the funding gaps across CFA elevating the issue beyond stakeholder advocacy, and assisting with cut through to the public who are often overwhelmed with mixed messaging and unsure of who to trust.
The report categorically demonstrates that CFA is severely underfunded and is not being provided the funding required to maintain a safe, reliable and fit for purpose fire truck fleet.
We call on Government and all sides of politics to formally commit to fully funding Victoria's fire services so they can do the critical job of protecting Victorians from fire and other emergencies.
Specifically, we want to see a fully funded commitment to a 10-year plan that addresses CFA's operational fire truck fleet and sets a nominal target for CFA Pumper's to be replaced at 15 years and CFA Tanker's to be replaced at 20 years. This will require an expedited build program and budget to address the large numbers of trucks aged well beyond their useful service life, including an uplift to the fire station replacement program to ensure modern replacement trucks will actually fit into fire stations.
And while recent Government announcements of extra funding are both welcomed and appreciated, the Auditor General's report confirms current funding commitments fall well short of the money required to fix CFA's ageing fleet.
Adam Barnett, Chief Executive Officer
Volunteer Fire Brigades Victoria.
About the Report
VAGO did this audit to see if the Country Fire Authority (CFA), the Department of Energy, Environment and Climate Action (DEECA) and Fire Rescue Victoria (FRV) are meeting their responsibilities to make sure their firefighting fleets are safe, reliable and capable of meeting operational needs.
VFBV regularly engages with oversight bodies to ensure the perspectives of volunteers is better understood across the emergency management sector. We engaged specifically with VAGO as they commenced their audit back in 2025 and engaged constructively throughout to help ensure the impacts of funding shortfalls across CFA in particular was well understood.
The Auditor General's report shows that Fire authorities vary considerably in how effectively they plan and maintain their fleets, and they are all facing government funding shortfalls.
The report states that Fire authorities need an estimated $1.5 billion between 2024–25 and 2033–34 to address critical fire truck replacement and upgrade needs. But they only have around one-quarter of the funding they need. CFA accounts for the largest share of this, with $962.5m required over the same 10-year period.
CFA and FRV have well-designed systems to plan their fleets. But some parts of their asset strategies are not fully in place, which limits their ability to respond to risks and needs.
DEECA’s fleet planning has significant gaps. It lacks strategic and operational plans, and it did not follow development and quality assurance processes for parts of its fleet. This led to widespread faults in DEECA’s fleet, which meant DEECA operated fire trucks that were overweight or had cracking. It removed over half of its fleet from service in 2025 to address these issues. It has since returned these trucks to service under ongoing monitoring and repair programs.
No fire authority is completing all its scheduled maintenance, which it predicts may lead to more breakdowns.
The report concludes that together, these issues increase the risk that fire authorities will not have enough fit-for-purpose fire trucks to respond to fires and other emergencies when required.
Report
The report outlines the following issues:
Fleet size and age
- - CFA has 2,208 operational fire trucks forming the overwhelming majority of Victoria's firefighting fleet. DEECA has 676, and FRV 184.
- - CFA's median truck age is 16.4 years, FRV's is 16.1 years, and DEECA's is 8.5 years.
- - CFA has 1,256 of those trucks over the age of 15 years, FRV has 110 over the age of 15 years, and DEECA has 45 over the age of 15 years.
Fleet Funding
- - Fire Authorities need $1.5 billion to replace and upgrade fire trucks between 2024 - 2034 financial years
- - CFA requires $962.5 million to replace 1,657 fire trucks aged beyond their useful life over the next 10 years.
- - FRV requires $297.3 million to replace 153 fire trucks over the same period and DEECA requires $216.6 million to replace 676 fire trucks including those that have cracking.
- - Both CFA and FRV each spend approximately $15 million a year on maintenance costs for their respective fleets.
- - Across the 2024/25 to 2026/27 State Budgets, fire authorities have received only 12.1% of the estimated funding they require to address issues across the fleet.
- - The report highlights supply chain issues affecting build programs, with 21 new fire trucks ordered in 2021/22 and only 4 having so far been received.
Government Interference
- - CFA, FRV and DEECA have not always asked for sufficient funding to address replacement and upgrade needs.
- - Despite agencies under quoting on what they required, government only approved 67% of recent CFA, FRV and DEECA funding proposals.
- - Including budget, grant and capital funding, fire authorities only received 26.7% of their estimated total funding needs for the operational truck fleet.
- - Between 2024/25 to 2026/27 budget periods, the Victorian Treasurer directed all Ministers to limit funding requests.
- - The Department of Justice and Community Safety reinforced this message to CFA and FRV who were preparing for increased fire risk but yet subsequently reduced their funding proposals to comply with government direction.
Fleet Plans and Maintenance
- - VAGO says CFA has a sound asset strategy and asset management plan, but some parts are not fully in place.
- - CFA and FRV allocate and rotate trucks to maximise coverage and reliability. DEECA does not.
- - This means rural and regional communities disproportionately carry the load of a higher percent of over age appliances with 82% of fire trucks aged over 25 years issued to remote or rural townships.
- - CFA completed 94.9% of its scheduled maintenance; DEECA completed 85.5%; and FRV completed 67.9%
- - CFA and FRV typically return trucks requiring repair to service within 4 weeks, with 50% being returned within 2 weeks.
- - Older trucks are more likely to have faults than younger trucks which creates extra maintenance work for aging fleets.
- - However, with an ageing fleet - limited parts and increasingly complex faults mean that some major faults are taking longer. This is increasing the risk of service gaps.
- - Unplanned repairs are increasing with CFA required to undertake 9,583 repairs in 2025, FRV 7,839 and DEECA 1,655
- - There is no consistent set of measurers to track the condition of Victoria's firefighting fleet, there are no targets and no reporting against these measures.
Recommendations
VAGO makes 6 recommendations:
1. strengthen their fleet asset management arrangements
2. complete all scheduled maintenance
3. improve the accuracy of maintenance forecasts
4. improve fleet condition and performance monitoring
5. DEECA to establish a fleet quality management system
6. All fire authorities and the Department of Justice and Community Safety to advise the government on fleet funding needs and the risks associated with funding gaps
